The referendum on the voting system – why I’ll be voting “No”.

It’s a funny old business, this referendum on the voting system. It’s become a bitter battle between those who don’t want a change in the system and those who don’t want the Alternative Vote ( AV) but see it as a sort of halfway house between First Past The Post (FPTP) and the real deal. That’s how simple it is. No one really wants AV but those who are running the Yes campaign aren’t honest enough to tell you that. They’re too wrapped up in their imaginations.

But those who support the No vote aren’t exactly covering themselves in glory either.  Their campaign has relied on emotional blackmail and cheap tricks. The campaign has adopted an ad hominem tone to it. Nick Clegg has become the object of ridicule for a campaign that has been orchestrated from the Tory side of the argument. Clegg apparently thinks that AV is a”miserable little compromise”. But he accepted AV as part of the coalition deal; he wasn’t politically savvy enough to spot a lemon when it was presented to him as a roadworthy vehicle. Clegg loves the high of being in government. It’s intoxicating.

What has really developed is  a phony war between the Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats – both of them in power but engaging in a little mudslinging for the benefit of the cameras. “Look” say the Lib Dems, “We’re a separate party, with our own identity”. But no one wants to hear it. No one is interested hearing how the Lib Dems are playing nice cop to the Tories’ nasty cop. We’ve read the script, seen the film. One cop is kneeing you in the goolies, while the other is offering to get you a cup of tea. They’re the perfect pair.

I’m voting “No”. Not because I want to screw the Lib Dems (they’ve done that to themselves) but because I don’t believe that AV is any better than FPTP. Proportional Representation in the form of real PR, as exists in Ireland with Single Transferable Vote system  (STV) or the Mixed Member Proportional voting system (MMP) as exists in Scotland, are the real ways forward. Even AV+ is a little better than this AV bollocks.

But do we really need a referendum on this issue NOW? My answer to that question is “no”.

Advertisements

4 Comments

Filed under Alternative Vote system, Government & politics

4 responses to “The referendum on the voting system – why I’ll be voting “No”.

  1. Nick Grimshaw

    Whilst it is both true and obvious that AV is not as good as PR with regards to Representing The Interests Of The Majority, I strongly believe that the Conservatives will treat a win for the No-vote as a sign that The Aforementioned Majority are happy with the voting system that they’ve got, thank-you-very-much, and subsequently you will never see another referendum on the voting-system – let alone PR – in this country for at least a generation.

    I’m voting “Yes” not because I believe that AV is the ideal solution, but because I believe that it’s the only option that will lead the way to further electoral reform.

    • This is what I’m saying: the Yes camp will use emotional blackmail (We’ll never get another chance to change the voting system). While the No camp will use baseless ad hominem attacks. As I pointed out in a much earlier blog, the referendum does not offer a real choice. AV was offered alongside FPTP in an attempt to scupper the PR debate. Cameron knows it isn’t PR. Clegg knows it isn’t PR. So why offer it as a ‘choice’? If the Yes to AV campaign should win, there still won’t be another chance to change the system for a generation. I think you’re deluding yourself if you think that is going to happen.

      I’m not happy with either AV or FPTP. My views and those of millions of others have been ignored. I may even spoil my ballot.

  2. Nick Grimshaw

    Even if it does turn out that this is the last referendum on electoral reform for a generation – and I believe that a win for Yes will make this the start of the conversation, rather than the end – I’d still rather be stuck with AV than FPTP because I think that, imperfect as it is, it’s still a better representation of the wishes of the majority.

    I sincerely hope anyone spoiling their ballot does so by listing their preferences for Yes/No numerically. 🙂

    • But you’re assuming that the campaign for PR will simply dry up and blow away if the “No” camp wins. It won’t.

      I sincerely hope anyone spoiling their ballot does so by listing their preferences for Yes/No numerically.

      Boom tish! 😛

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s